What's Happening to Our Vendors?

The McKinsey Problem

Some thoughts for CAUCUS on where this is all heading


OK, So Here's What Got Me Thinking...

Couple weeks ago I'm reading about McKinsey cutting 5,000 people. Then Deloitte, then PwC.

Then I'm looking at our vendor list and thinking... half these firms are probably next.

Started digging into why some professional services are getting hammered while others seem fine.

Turns out there's a pattern.


The "Oh Crap" Moment

Remember when we paid Accenture $400/hour for junior analysts to do data migration assessments?

Last month a startup bid the same work for $50K flat fee using AI tools.

We're not just buying different solutions, we're watching entire business models collapse in real time.


What I'm Calling the "McKinsey Bucket"

Firms that built their whole thing around:

  • Selling expensive human thinking time

  • Premium pricing because "we're the experts"

  • Armies of junior people doing analysis work

  • Time and materials everything

Sound familiar? Check your approved vendor list.


The Pattern I'm Seeing

Companies getting demolished:

  • McKinsey (duh)

  • Big Four accounting - mass layoffs everywhere

  • Traditional IT consultants with huge T&M practices

  • System integrators who just throw bodies at problems

Companies doing fine:

  • Boutique specialists with real relationships

  • Firms doing work AI can't touch

  • Anyone who moved off billable hours years ago

There's definitely something here.


My Vendor Risk "Test"

Been running this mental checklist on our vendors:

Red Flags:

  • Do they bill mostly time & materials?

  • Could AI probably do 60% of what their junior people do?

  • Are their deliverables pretty templated/predictable?

  • Do we pay extra just for their brand name?

Green Flags:

  • Real relationships with our team

  • Each project is genuinely different

  • Senior people doing the actual work

  • Fixed price or outcome-based deals

Not scientific, but it's been scary accurate so far


Some Real Examples

That big IT consulting firm (you know the one):

  • 80% of our contracts are T&M

  • Teams of analysts who basically fill out templates

  • Same "assessment methodology" every time

  • We pay $250/hour because... reasons? This screams trouble to me

The security boutique we love:

  • Fixed price penetration testing

  • Same two senior guys always do our work

  • Every report is completely custom

  • We work with them because they actually get our environment These guys will be fine


What I Think This Means for Us

Short term - probably some good deals coming up as desperate vendors compete

Medium term - need backup plans for our high-risk relationships

Long term - whole vendor landscape is going to look different

Also, our internal teams might need to get comfortable managing AI tools directly instead of paying consultants to do it


The Tricky Part

Some of our "risky" vendors do bring value.

Like, yes, that big systems integrator probably has an outdated business model. But they also know our infrastructure inside and out, and switching mid-project would be a nightmare.

So it's not just "find new vendors." It's figuring out who can transform vs. who's actually doomed.


What you can do about it

With high-risk vendors:

  • Having honest conversations about where this is heading

  • Asking about their AI strategy (not just buzzword stuff)

  • Building more fixed-price deals into new contracts

  • Starting to identify alternatives... just in case

With good vendors:

  • Being more strategic about the relationship

  • Helping them understand what we actually value

  • Working together on pilot projects with new approaches

Internally:

  • Building more AI literacy on our team

  • Getting better at scoping work that's really outcome-focused

  • Documenting what we actually need vs. what vendors tell us we need


Honest Questions I Don't Have Answers For

  • How fast is this really happening? 2 years? 5 years?

  • Are we missing opportunities by being too loyal to existing vendors?

  • Should we be more aggressive about testing AI-native alternatives?

  • What happens to all those people who get laid off from consulting firms?

  • Are we going to end up doing more of this work internally?

Would love to hear what others are seeing


Things to Watch

I'm keeping an eye on:

  • Which vendors start pushing back on fixed-price contracts

  • Who's having trouble keeping senior people

  • New competitors showing up with AI-powered pitches

  • Our own project costs - are we paying more for worse results?

  • Vendor financial health (some of these firms are burning cash)

Also watching which CAUCUS members are having similar conversations


Bottom Line

Look, maybe I'm wrong about all this. Maybe these firms will all figure it out.

But I'd rather be paranoid and prepared than surprised when a key vendor implodes in the middle of a critical project.

And honestly? This might be the biggest shift in professional services we'll see in our careers. Worth taking seriously.


Let's Talk

What are you seeing with your vendors?

Anyone else having these conversations? Found good alternatives to traditional players? Horror stories about vendor failures?

Really curious what's happening across different industries and company sizes


Next Steps (Maybe?)

If there's interest, could be worth:

  • Sharing notes on vendor performance across the community

  • Building a list of emerging alternatives worth testing

  • Collaborating on contract language that protects us better

  • Maybe inviting some of these "transformation" vendors to present?

Or maybe I'm overthinking it and everything will be fine